By October 15, 2013 4 Comments Read More →

Matching by Race and Gender in STEM-based Mentoring Relationships

Matching by Race and Gender in STEM-based Mentoring Relationships - The Chronicles of Evidence-Based MentoringBlake-Beard, S. (2011)., Matching by Race and Gender in Mentoring Relationships: Keeping our Eyes on the Prize.  Journal of Social Issues, Vol. 67, No. 3, 2011, pp. 622–643

Dr. Stacy Blake-Beard, whose work focuses on college and graduate student mentoring, opens her piece by noting that it is often difficult to pinpoint all the factors that can contribute to successful  mentoring relationships and outcomes. The most successful pairings are those based on a shared commonality between the mentor and the mentee. For example, matching on race and gender has been shown to be an effective strategy for helping female and students of color remain in science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) fields.

In this study, Blake-Beard research focuses the following questions:

  • Do mentees express a preference for (and seek) mentors who share their race and gender?
  • Does matching on the basis of race and gender affect the mentoring experience and outcomes?

The study also documents the effect of race and gender matching on three academic outcomes:

  • Grade Point Average (self-reported)
  • Efficacy
  • Confidence

Method

Respondents selected from the over 7,000 undergraduate and graduate students and postdoctoral scholars actively participating in MentorNet’s online community, completed an online survey.  MentorNet’s mission is to “foster a pervasive culture of mentoring in STEM fields that readily transfers expertise and experience from professional to students”. Survey respondents were in STEM studies or STEM-related business fields exclusively. Approximately one third (1,013) of those invited to participate returned completed surveys. The online survey included questions about respondents’ personal history and experiences with mentoring, their demographics, their academic details and included questions regarding the results of any previous mentoring experiences as detailed here:

Participants were categorized based on their gender, race, academics, and as well as their preferences and experiences with mentoring. Participants were identified by the strength of their desire to be mentored by similar race and gender mentors as well as the level of importance they placed on race or gender matching. In addition, mentees were asked about:

  • Support from Mentor–Participants were asked to assess the level of psychosocial (mutual respect, consistency etc), instrumental (new skills, opportunities, challenging assignments etc) and role-modeling help they received.
  • Academic Outcomes–Three academic outcomes were measured: self-reported GPA, academic self-efficacy, and achievement.

Results

  • Having a mentor of one’s own gender or race was felt to be important by many of the women and students of color.
  • Students who had a mentor of their own gender or race reported receiving more help
  • However, matching by race or gender did not appear to affect academic outcomes – even though students were more satisfied with their mentoring experience and believed race and/or gender matching to be important.

Blake-Beard points out, however, this complex result may be because gender and race are a poor proxy for other, more meaningful commonality matches. Additionally, the benefits of same race/gender mentoring may not be immediately measurable.

Implications

More research is needed regarding all aspects of matching – not just race and gender. Nevertheless, as Blake-Beard notes, the results have implications for diversity and mentoring. Matching on the basis of demographic characteristics such as race and gender may aid in creating more trusting bonds, leading to deeper and earlier connections.  In the end, however, what might matter most is matching mentee needs with that which the mentor can provide.  Summarized by Micheline Mann 

4 Comments on "Matching by Race and Gender in STEM-based Mentoring Relationships"

Trackback | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Stacy Blake-Beard says:

    I am delighted to see this article featured on a website dedicated to encouraging dialogue around what we are learning about mentoring through research. Thank you to the two commenters–MentorNet is an organization that has made a difference, particularly for women in STEM fields. I appreciate the second commenter’s thoughts–her comment supports what we found in our research. Race and gender are important but finding other areas of similarity may be as critical. This article is not mine alone–I had three co-authors whom I would like to make sure are acknowledged. It was really a pleasure working with the former president of MentorNet (Dr. Carol Muller), one of my mentors (Dr. Faye Crosby) and one of her colleagues (Dr. Melissa Bayne).

  2. H. Christensen says:

    re: MentorNet
    fantastic org – love it!

  3. Alexis Cavanagh says:

    As a female student of colour, I know that being mentored by my same race and or gender would not matter to me so much as matching more important factors – like goals, communication styles, enthusiasm levels etc. Nevertheless, an interesting discussion that cannot help but further our understanding of what makes mentoring work even better.

Post a Comment